Shortly before her death, Rachel Caroline Eaton, AM 1911, PhD 1919 (1869–1938), completed a revolutionary history of the Cherokee Nation. In 2025 her landmark work was finally published.
In Cherokee tradition, women are considered the “fire carriers”—those who tend and regenerate the life and memories of the nation.
To many in the Cherokee Nation, Rachel Caroline “Callie” Eaton, AM 1911, PhD 1919, is one of the greatest fire carriers of all. A respected Cherokee historian and educator, Eaton received her PhD from the University of Chicago—a rare, even unheard-of, level of education for a Native American woman of that period to achieve.
While enrolled at the University, she wrote John Ross and the Cherokee Indians (George Banta Publishing Company, 1914), a study of the Cherokee Nation’s longest-serving chief. The book’s section on Indian Removal is still widely cited.
Today the Trail of Tears is one of the few aspects of Native American history many people know. Eaton is “part of the reason why,” says Patricia Dawson, an assistant professor of history at Mount Holyoke College.
To Dawson and celebrated Cherokee beadwork artist Martha Berry, Eaton is simply “Aunt Callie.” Berry is Eaton’s great-niece; Dawson is Eaton’s great-great-great-niece and Berry’s first cousin twice removed. Though they never met Eaton, her memory was kept vibrant enough for them to feel as though they did.
“She fought like a Cherokee. She would stand her ground,” Berry says in a call from her home in Rowlett, Texas. “She was a very strong, powerful woman in a time when women weren’t allowed to be that.”
Had she only written John Ross and the Cherokee Indians, Eaton’s place in Native American scholarship and historiography would already be assured. But family, scholars, and history buffs always knew another work of hers lay in unpublished repose: the epic A History of the Cherokee Nation, her life’s work. Ninety years after Eaton first submitted it for publication, the book—edited by Dawson, Berry, and Berry’s husband, Dave, a retired journalist—was at long last published by the University of Oklahoma Press in December 2025.
Eaton had raced to complete the manuscript before dying of breast cancer in 1938, but there was another reason for her urgency. Eaton envisioned the book, Berry says, as “almost an obituary for the Cherokee Nation,” ravaged as it was by generations of reneged-upon treaties with the US government, forced removal, the devastating land allotments of the Dawes Act, and the dissolution of the nation’s governmental autonomy. The book ends in 1907 with the admittance of Oklahoma into the union, after the United States jettisoned a proposal to create a Native American state, Sequoyah, alongside it.
“She thought [the Cherokee Nation] was dying, and that she needed to write the history because it would be forgotten,” Dave Berry says.
Eaton’s standpoint—that of “a citizen by blood, reared in the nation, heir to its traditions, and beneficiary of its tribal institutions,” as she put it—makes A History of the Cherokee Nation an incisive, distinctive work of scholarship. Today some details even seem prescient: Twice, Eaton uses the term concentration camp to describe the short-term settlements Cherokees were forced into during Indian Removal. In just a few short years, the term would take on new weight as Allied forces liberated Nazi camps in Europe.
But Eaton’s personal stake also alienated prospective publishers. In 1935 Eaton submitted A History to the University of Oklahoma Press. The press rejected her manuscript, citing its “too partisan, pro-Cherokee point of view.”
Even as the book traded hands from Eaton to her nephew to, finally, the Berrys, the rejections continued. One prospective publisher expressed concern over the book’s discussion of formerly enslaved Black Cherokees and their descendants, known as the Cherokee Freedmen. (The published book contains an editorial note about this material, explaining that Eaton “sometimes uses outdated and prejudiced language in her discussions of Cherokee Freedmen’s history.”) In all, Berry estimates that six or seven publishers passed on the manuscript.
But eventually, Dave Berry says, “it became Callie’s time.” Dawson’s credentials and involvement helped give the book a boost, as did interest by other Indigenous studies scholars, including Farina King, Horizon Endowed Chair of Native American Ecology and Culture in the Department of Native American Studies at the University of Oklahoma, who contributed a chapter on Eaton to This Land Is Herland: Gendered Activism in Oklahoma from the 1870s to the 2010s (University of Oklahoma Press, 2021).
“There’s renewed interest in thinking about Cherokee women’s perspectives,” Dawson says.
Eaton was born in 1869 near Flint Creek, Oklahoma, in what was then known as Indian Territory (today the Cherokee reservation in northeastern Oklahoma). Her mother’s mother, Lucy Ward Williams, had walked the Trail of Tears; her father was a White Civil War veteran who had fought for the Confederacy. Eaton was briefly married in 1901, but the union was either annulled or ended in divorce—an episode little discussed in the family, due to taboos at the time, as well as the matrilineal focus of Cherokee culture.
Eaton attended and taught in the Cherokee Nation’s lauded self-administered network of public schools, which were unusual, as most Native nations’ schools at the time were administered by religious groups or by the US or Canadian governments. She received a top-notch education from the Cherokee Female Seminary—an institution modeled after Mount Holyoke College, where Dawson now teaches—graduating in 1887. (Cherokee women attended Mount Holyoke as early as the 1840s.)
Education and heritage were everything to Eaton. The development of the Cherokee school system is among the most powerful and unabashedly proud throughlines in A History of the Cherokee Nation. When she wasn’t working on the book, Eaton contributed articles on Cherokee history—particularly military history—to the Tulsa World, one of the city’s leading dailies, bringing her research to a broader audience. The value of education was imparted to Berry’s generation; she would break up long hours of studying Latin, literature, psychology, and the sciences with Saturday night stomp dances. In an episode that has become infamous in family lore, Eaton had a brief falling-out with Berry’s father over his decision to drop out of college and focus on his job during the Great Depression. Eaton was so enraged that she moved out of the small apartment they shared in Tulsa.
“Lots of family members described her as being very strict,” Dawson says, “but also that she was the one who passed down the importance of remembering who we are.”
Little is known about Eaton’s time at the University of Chicago; her only documented student activity is membership in a club for students from the South. By 1916 she’d left Chicago, after her master’s degree but before her PhD, to become a history professor at Lake Erie College in Painesville, Ohio. Further appointments would follow at the Industrial Institute and College of Mississippi in Columbus and at Trinity University (then located in Waxahachie, Texas), where she became dean of women. Upon returning to Oklahoma she was elected as school superintendent in Rogers County in 1920. (Berry’s father chauffeured her to campaign stops.)
Eaton’s time in Chicago seems to have profoundly shaped A History of the Cherokee Nation. Taking pride of place in the book’s acknowledgments is Sophonisba Breckinridge, PhM 1897, PhD 1901, JD 1904, the prominent social reformer who helped establish what is now the Crown Family School of Social Work, Policy, and Practice as a graduate institution within the University. Eaton thanks Breckinridge last and most effusively, even more than her physician—whom she credited as “instrumental in lengthening the span of my life, thereby making possible the completion of this volume.”
Eaton titled the book’s third chapter “A Century of Progress,” enumerating Cherokee luminaries and accomplishments in the 18th and 19th centuries. Dawson suspects that name is in dialogue with both the tagline of the 1933–34 Chicago World’s Fair—an ashtray from the exposition ended up in the family’s belongings, possibly through Eaton—and activist Helen Hunt Jackson’s 1881 book A Century of Dishonor: A Sketch of the United States Government’s Dealings with Some of the Indian Tribes (Harper & Brothers), which protested the US government’s mistreatment of Native people.
As that choice of chapter title demonstrates, Eaton’s History emphasizes Native self-sufficiency and empowerment rather than the dominant narrative of weakness and passivity promulgated by non-Native historians and writers. For example, many historians point out that the US government didn’t provide enough doctors on the Trail of Tears. “But she’s saying, ‘No, we weren’t allowed to go and gather medicine,’” Dawson says. “We have our own ways of medicine and … we have our own doctors. We don’t need other people to come and provide doctors.”
In her introduction to A History of the Cherokee Nation, Dawson writes that Eaton was likely the first Native American woman to receive a PhD in the United States, though, she says, “we can’t know for sure.” She sees herself, Berry, and Eaton as the inheritors of histories kept by “multiple generations of Cherokee women family members.” Eaton credits two in the book: her grandmother, Lucy Ward Williams, whom she calls “one of the last of the fireside historians of her tribe,” and an earlier ancestor, Nancy Ward (Nanyehi in Cherokee), an 18th-century political leader and de facto diplomat to the Euro-American settler population.
“The fact that she points out other Cherokee women who don’t have PhDs as scholars, as historians … feels groundbreaking,” Dawson says. “There’s so much pressure in academia to only think about academic historians as historians.”
As an honored figure in the Cherokee Nation and a titan in her own field, Berry made the beadworked bandolier bag featured on the cover of A History of the Cherokee Nation, which references the Cherokees’ fire origin story. As the tale goes, many animals tried and failed to capture fire from an island. Only a tiny spider succeeded, ferrying a single ember across the water’s surface in a web-woven bowl on her back to bring fire to her friends. Berry’s beadwork, titled “Our Fires Still Burn,” depicts that tiny yet mighty water spider—the Cherokees’ first fire carrier.
“I get choked up every time I hear that story,” Berry says. “Because, by god, that’s a little woman who was tenacious, stood her ground, did the hard work, and achieved greatness.”
Hannah Edgar, AB’18, is a Chicago-based freelance writer.